# Knowledge Distillation + [Knowledge Distillation](#0) + [1. Introduction](#1) - [1.1 Introduction to Knowledge Distillation](#11) - [1.2 Introduction to PaddleOCR Knowledge Distillation](#12) + [2. Configuration File Analysis](#2) + [2.1 Recognition Model Configuration File Analysis](#21) - [2.1.1 Model Structure](#211) - [2.1.2 Loss Function ](#212) - [2.1.3 Post-processing](#213) - [2.1.4 Metric Calculation](#214) - [2.1.5 Fine-tuning Distillation Model](#215) + [2.2 Detection Model Configuration File Analysis](#22) - [2.2.1 Model Structure](#221) - [2.2.2 Loss Function](#222) - [2.2.3 Post-processing](#223) - [2.2.4 Metric Calculation](#224) - [2.2.5 Fine-tuning Distillation Model](#225) ## 1. Introduction ### 1.1 Introduction to Knowledge Distillation In recent years, deep neural networks have been proved to be an extremely effective method for solving problems in the fields of computer vision and natural language processing. By constructing a suitable neural network and training it, the performance metrics of the final network model will basically exceed the traditional algorithm. When the amount of data is large enough, increasing the amount of parameters by constructing a reasonable network model can significantly improve the performance of the model, but this brings about the problem of a sharp increase in the complexity of the model. Large models are more expensive to use in actual scenarios. Deep neural networks generally have more parameter redundancy. At present, there are several main methods to compress the model and reduce the amount of its parameters. Such as pruning, quantification, knowledge distillation, etc., where knowledge distillation refers to the use of teacher models to guide student models to learn specific tasks, to ensure that the small model obtains a relatively large performance improvement under the condition of unchanged parameters. In addition, in the knowledge distillation task, a mutual learning model training method was also derived. The paper [Deep Mutual Learning](https://arxiv.org/abs/1706.00384) pointed out that using two identical models to supervise each other during the training process can achieve better results than a single model training. ### 1.2 Introduction to PaddleOCR Knowledge Distillation Whether it is a large model distilling a small model, or a small model learning from each other and updating parameters, they are essentially the output between different models or mutual supervision between feature maps. The only difference is (1) whether the model requires fixed parameters. (2) Whether the model needs to be loaded with a pre-trained model. For the case where a large model distills a small model, the large model generally needs to load the pre-trained model and fix the parameters. For the situation where small models distill each other, the small models generally do not load the pre-trained model, and the parameters are also in a learnable state. In the task of knowledge distillation, it is not only the distillation between two models, but also the situation where multiple models learn from each other. Therefore, in the knowledge distillation code framework, it is also necessary to support this type of distillation method. The algorithm of knowledge distillation is integrated in PaddleOCR. Specifically, it has the following main features: - It supports mutual learning of any network, and does not require the sub-network structure to be completely consistent or to have a pre-trained model. At the same time, there is no limit to the number of sub-networks, just add it in the configuration file. - Support arbitrarily configuring the loss function through the configuration file, not only can use a certain loss, but also a combination of multiple losses. - Support all model-related environments such as knowledge distillation training, prediction, evaluation, and export, which is convenient for use and deployment. Through knowledge distillation, in the common Chinese and English text recognition task, without adding any time-consuming prediction, the accuracy of the model can be improved by more than 3%. Combining the learning rate adjustment strategy and the model structure fine-tuning strategy, the final improvement is more than 5%. ## 2. Configuration File Analysis In the process of knowledge distillation training, there is no change in data preprocessing, optimizer, learning rate, and some global attributes. The configuration files of the model structure, loss function, post-processing, metric calculation and other modules need to be fine-tuned. The following takes the knowledge distillation configuration file for recognition and detection as an example to analyze the training and configuration of knowledge distillation. ### 2.1 Recognition Model Configuration File Analysis The configuration file is in [ch_PP-OCRv2_rec_distillation.yml](../../configs/rec/ch_PP-OCRv2/ch_PP-OCRv2_rec_distillation.yml). #### 2.1.1 Model Structure In the knowledge distillation task, the model structure configuration is as follows. ```yaml Architecture: model_type: &model_type "rec" # Model category, recognition, detection, etc. name: DistillationModel # Structure name, in the distillation task, it is DistillationModel algorithm: Distillation # Algorithm name Models: # Model, including the configuration information of the subnet Teacher: # The name of the subnet, it must include at least the `pretrained` and `freeze_params` parameters, and the other parameters are the construction parameters of the subnet pretrained: # Does this sub-network need to load pre-training weights freeze_params: false # Do you need fixed parameters return_all_feats: true # Do you need to return all features, if it is False, only the final output is returned model_type: *model_type # Model category algorithm: SVTR # The algorithm name of the sub-network. The remaining parameters of the sub-network are consistent with the general model training configuration Transform: Backbone: name: MobileNetV1Enhance scale: 0.5 last_conv_stride: [1, 2] last_pool_type: avg Head: name: MultiHead head_list: - CTCHead: Neck: name: svtr dims: 64 depth: 2 hidden_dims: 120 use_guide: True Head: fc_decay: 0.00001 - SARHead: enc_dim: 512 max_text_length: *max_text_length Student: # Another sub-network, here is a distillation example of DML, the two sub-networks have the same structure, and both need to learn parameters pretrained: # The following parameters are the same as above freeze_params: false return_all_feats: true model_type: *model_type algorithm: SVTR Transform: Backbone: name: MobileNetV1Enhance scale: 0.5 last_conv_stride: [1, 2] last_pool_type: avg Head: name: MultiHead head_list: - CTCHead: Neck: name: svtr dims: 64 depth: 2 hidden_dims: 120 use_guide: True Head: fc_decay: 0.00001 - SARHead: enc_dim: 512 max_text_length: *max_text_length ``` If you want to add more sub-networks for training, you can also add the corresponding fields in the configuration file according to the way of adding `Student` and `Teacher`. For example, if you want 3 models to supervise each other and train together, then `Architecture` can be written in the following format. ```yaml Architecture: model_type: &model_type "rec" name: DistillationModel algorithm: Distillation Models: Teacher: pretrained: freeze_params: false return_all_feats: true model_type: *model_type algorithm: SVTR Transform: Backbone: name: MobileNetV1Enhance scale: 0.5 last_conv_stride: [1, 2] last_pool_type: avg Head: name: MultiHead head_list: - CTCHead: Neck: name: svtr dims: 64 depth: 2 hidden_dims: 120 use_guide: True Head: fc_decay: 0.00001 - SARHead: enc_dim: 512 max_text_length: *max_text_length Student: pretrained: freeze_params: false return_all_feats: true model_type: *model_type algorithm: SVTR Transform: Backbone: name: MobileNetV1Enhance scale: 0.5 last_conv_stride: [1, 2] last_pool_type: avg Head: name: MultiHead head_list: - CTCHead: Neck: name: svtr dims: 64 depth: 2 hidden_dims: 120 use_guide: True Head: fc_decay: 0.00001 - SARHead: enc_dim: 512 max_text_length: *max_text_length Student2: pretrained: freeze_params: false return_all_feats: true model_type: *model_type algorithm: SVTR Transform: Backbone: name: MobileNetV1Enhance scale: 0.5 last_conv_stride: [1, 2] last_pool_type: avg Head: name: MultiHead head_list: - CTCHead: Neck: name: svtr dims: 64 depth: 2 hidden_dims: 120 use_guide: True Head: fc_decay: 0.00001 - SARHead: enc_dim: 512 max_text_length: *max_text_length ``` When the model is finally trained, it contains 3 sub-networks: `Teacher`, `Student`, `Student2`. The specific implementation code of the `DistillationModel` class can refer to [distillation_model.py](../../ppocr/modeling/architectures/distillation_model.py). The final model output is a dictionary, the key is the name of all the sub-networks, for example, here are `Student` and `Teacher`, and the value is the output of the corresponding sub-network, which can be `Tensor` (only the last layer of the network is returned) and `dict` (also returns the characteristic information in the middle). In the recognition task, in order to add more loss functions and ensure the scalability of the distillation method, the output of each sub-network is saved as a `dict`, which contains the sub-module output. Take the recognition model as an example. The output result of each sub-network is `dict`, the key contains `backbone_out`, `neck_out`, `head_out`, and `value` is the tensor of the corresponding module. Finally, for the above configuration file, `DistillationModel` The output format is as follows. ```json { "Teacher": { "backbone_out": tensor, "neck_out": tensor, "head_out": tensor, }, "Student": { "backbone_out": tensor, "neck_out": tensor, "head_out": tensor, } } ``` #### 2.1.2 Loss Function In the knowledge distillation task, the loss function configuration is as follows. ```yaml Loss: name: CombinedLoss # Loss function name loss_config_list: # List of loss function configuration files, mandatory functions for CombinedLoss - DistillationCTCLoss: # CTC loss function based on distillation, inherited from standard CTC loss weight: 1.0 # The weight of the loss function. In loss_config_list, each loss function must include this field model_name_list: ["Student", "Teacher"] # For the prediction results of the distillation model, extract the output of these two sub-networks and calculate the CTC loss with gt key: head_out # In the sub-network output dict, take the corresponding tensor - DistillationDMLLoss: # DML loss function, inherited from the standard DMLLoss weight: 1.0 act: "softmax" # Activation function, use it to process the input, can be softmax, sigmoid or None, the default is None model_name_pairs: # The subnet name pair used to calculate DML loss. If you want to calculate the DML loss of other subnets, you can continue to add it below the list - ["Student", "Teacher"] key: head_out multi_head: True # whether to use mult_head dis_head: ctc # assign the head name to calculate loss name: dml_ctc # prefix name of the loss - DistillationDMLLoss: # DML loss function, inherited from the standard DMLLoss weight: 0.5 act: "softmax" # Activation function, use it to process the input, can be softmax, sigmoid or None, the default is None model_name_pairs: # The subnet name pair used to calculate DML loss. If you want to calculate the DML loss of other subnets, you can continue to add it below the list - ["Student", "Teacher"] key: head_out multi_head: True # whether to use mult_head dis_head: sar # assign the head name to calculate loss name: dml_sar # prefix name of the loss - DistillationDistanceLoss: # Distilled distance loss function weight: 1.0 mode: "l2" # Support l1, l2 or smooth_l1 model_name_pairs: # Calculate the distance loss of the subnet name pair - ["Student", "Teacher"] key: backbone_out - DistillationSARLoss: # SAR loss function based on distillation, inherited from standard SAR loss weight: 1.0 # The weight of the loss function. In loss_config_list, each loss function must include this field model_name_list: ["Student", "Teacher"] # For the prediction results of the distillation model, extract the output of these two sub-networks and calculate the SAR loss with gt key: head_out # In the sub-network output dict, take the corresponding tensor multi_head: True # whether it is multi-head or not, if true, SAR branch is used to calculate the loss ``` Among the above loss functions, all distillation loss functions are inherited from the standard loss function class. The main functions are: Analyze the output of the distillation model, find the intermediate node (tensor) used to calculate the loss, and then use the standard loss function class to calculate. Taking the above configuration as an example, the final distillation training loss function contains the following five parts. - CTC branch of the final output `head_out` for `Student` and `Teacher` calculates the CTC loss with gt (loss weight equals 1.0). Here, because both sub-networks need to update the parameters, both of them need to calculate the loss with gt. - SAR branch of the final output `head_out` for `Student` and `Teacher` calculates the SAR loss with gt (loss weight equals 1.0). Here, because both sub-networks need to update the parameters, both of them need to calculate the loss with gt. - DML loss between CTC branch of `Student` and `Teacher`'s final output `head_out` (loss weight equals 1.0). - DML loss between SAR branch of `Student` and `Teacher`'s final output `head_out` (loss weight equals 0.5). - L2 loss between `Student` and `Teacher`'s backbone network output `backbone_out` (loss weight equals 1.0). For more specific implementation of `CombinedLoss`, please refer to: [combined_loss.py](../../ppocr/losses/combined_loss.py#L23). For more specific implementations of distillation loss functions such as `DistillationCTCLoss`, please refer to [distillation_loss.py](../../ppocr/losses/distillation_loss.py) #### 2.1.3 Post-processing In the knowledge distillation task, the post-processing configuration is as follows. ```yaml PostProcess: name: DistillationCTCLabelDecode # CTC decoding post-processing of distillation tasks, inherited from the standard CTCLabelDecode class model_name: ["Student", "Teacher"] # For the prediction results of the distillation model, extract the outputs of these two sub-networks and decode them key: head_out # Take the corresponding tensor in the subnet output dict multi_head: True # whether it is multi-head or not, if true, CTC branch is used to calculate the loss ``` Taking the above configuration as an example, the CTC decoding output of the two sub-networks `Student` and `Teahcer` will be calculated at the same time. Among them, `key` is the name of the subnet, and `value` is the list of subnets. For more specific implementation of `DistillationCTCLabelDecode`, please refer to: [rec_postprocess.py](../../ppocr/postprocess/rec_postprocess.py#L128) #### 2.1.4 Metric Calculation In the knowledge distillation task, the metric calculation configuration is as follows. ```yaml Metric: name: DistillationMetric # CTC decoding post-processing of distillation tasks, inherited from the standard CTCLabelDecode class base_metric_name: RecMetric # The base class of indicator calculation. For the output of the model, the indicator will be calculated based on this class main_indicator: acc # The name of the indicator key: "Student" # Select the main_indicator of this subnet as the criterion for saving the best model ignore_space: False # whether to ignore space during evaulation ``` Taking the above configuration as an example, the accuracy metric of the `Student` subnet will be used as the judgment metric for saving the best model. At the same time, the accuracy metric of all subnets will be printed out in the log. For more specific implementation of `DistillationMetric`, please refer to: [distillation_metric.py](../../ppocr/metrics/distillation_metric.py#L24). #### 2.1.5 Fine-tuning Distillation Model There are two ways to fine-tune the recognition distillation task. 1. Fine-tuning based on knowledge distillation: this situation is relatively simple, download the pre-trained model. Then configure the pre-training model path and your own data path in [ch_PP-OCRv2_rec_distillation.yml](../../configs/rec/PP-OCRv3/ch_PP-OCRv3_rec_distillation.yml) to perform fine-tuning training of the model. 2. Do not use knowledge distillation in fine-tuning: In this case, you need to first extract the student model parameters from the pre-training model. The specific steps are as follows. - First download the pre-trained model and unzip it. ```shell wget https://paddleocr.bj.bcebos.com/PP-OCRv3/chinese/ch_PP-OCRv3_rec_train.tar tar -xf ch_PP-OCRv3_rec_train.tar ``` - Then use python to extract the student model parameters ```python import paddle # Load the pre-trained model all_params = paddle.load("ch_PP-OCRv3_rec_train/best_accuracy.pdparams") # View the keys of the weight parameter print(all_params.keys()) # Weight extraction of student model s_params = {key[len("Student."):]: all_params[key] for key in all_params if "Student." in key} # View the keys of the weight parameters of the student model print(s_params.keys()) # Save weight parameters paddle.save(s_params, "ch_PP-OCRv3_rec_train/student.pdparams") ``` After the extraction is complete, use [ch_PP-OCRv3_rec.yml](../../configs/rec/PP-OCRv3/ch_PP-OCRv3_rec.yml) to modify the path of the pre-trained model (the path of the exported `student.pdparams` model) and your own data path to fine-tune the model. ### 2.2 Detection Model Configuration File Analysis The configuration file of the detection model distillation is in the ```PaddleOCR/configs/det/ch_PP-OCRv3/``` directory, which contains three distillation configuration files: - ```ch_PP-OCRv3_det_cml.yml```, Use one large model to distill two small models, and the two small models learn from each other - ```ch_PP-OCRv3_det_dml.yml```, Method of mutual distillation of two student models #### 2.2.1 Model Structure In the knowledge distillation task, the model structure configuration is as follows: ``` Architecture: name: DistillationModel # Structure name, in the distillation task, it is DistillationModel algorithm: Distillation # Algorithm name Models: # Model, including the configuration information of the subnet Student: # The name of the subnet, it must include at least the `pretrained` and `freeze_params` parameters, and the other parameters are the construction parameters of the subnet pretrained: ./pretrain_models/MobileNetV3_large_x0_5_pretrained # Does this sub-network need to load pre-training weights freeze_params: false # Do you need fixed parameters return_all_feats: false # Do you need to return all features, if it is False, only the final output is returned model_type: det algorithm: DB Backbone: name: ResNet in_channels: 3 layers: 50 Neck: name: LKPAN out_channels: 256 Head: name: DBHead kernel_list: [7,2,2] k: 50 Teacher: # Another sub-network, here is a distillation example of a large model distill a small model pretrained: ./pretrain_models/ch_ppocr_server_v2.0_det_train/best_accuracy return_all_feats: false model_type: det algorithm: DB Transform: Backbone: name: ResNet in_channels: 3 layers: 50 Neck: name: LKPAN out_channels: 256 Head: name: DBHead kernel_list: [7,2,2] k: 50 ``` If DML is used, that is, the method of two small models learning from each other, the Teacher network structure in the above configuration file needs to be set to the same configuration as the Student model. Refer to the configuration file for details. [ch_PP-OCRv3_det_dml.yml](../../configs/det/ch_PP-OCRv3/ch_PP-OCRv3_det_dml.yml) The following describes the configuration file parameters [ch_PP-OCRv3_det_cml.yml](../../configs/det/ch_PP-OCRv3/ch_PP-OCRv3_det_cml.yml): ``` Architecture: name: DistillationModel algorithm: Distillation model_type: det Models: Teacher: # Teacher model configuration of CML distillation pretrained: ./pretrain_models/ch_ppocr_server_v2.0_det_train/best_accuracy freeze_params: true # Teacher does not train return_all_feats: false model_type: det algorithm: DB Transform: Backbone: name: ResNet in_channels: 3 layers: 50 Neck: name: LKPAN out_channels: 256 Head: name: DBHead kernel_list: [7,2,2] k: 50 Student: # Student model configuration for CML distillation pretrained: ./pretrain_models/MobileNetV3_large_x0_5_pretrained freeze_params: false return_all_feats: false model_type: det algorithm: DB Backbone: name: MobileNetV3 scale: 0.5 model_name: large disable_se: true Neck: name: RSEFPN out_channels: 96 shortcut: True Head: name: DBHead k: 50 Student2: # Student2 model configuration for CML distillation pretrained: ./pretrain_models/MobileNetV3_large_x0_5_pretrained freeze_params: false return_all_feats: false model_type: det algorithm: DB Transform: Backbone: name: MobileNetV3 scale: 0.5 model_name: large disable_se: true Neck: name: RSEFPN out_channels: 96 shortcut: True Head: name: DBHead k: 50 ``` The specific implementation code of the distillation model `DistillationModel` class can refer to [distillation_model.py](../../ppocr/modeling/architectures/distillation_model.py). The final model output is a dictionary, the key is the name of all the sub-networks, for example, here are `Student` and `Teacher`, and the value is the output of the corresponding sub-network, which can be `Tensor` (only the last layer of the network is returned) and `dict` (also returns the characteristic information in the middle). In the distillation task, in order to facilitate the addition of the distillation loss function, the output of each network is saved as a `dict`, which contains the sub-module output. The key contains `backbone_out`, `neck_out`, `head_out`, and `value` is the tensor of the corresponding module. Finally, for the above configuration file, the output format of `DistillationModel` is as follows. ```json { "Teacher": { "backbone_out": tensor, "neck_out": tensor, "head_out": tensor, }, "Student": { "backbone_out": tensor, "neck_out": tensor, "head_out": tensor, } } ``` #### 2.2.2 Loss Function The distillation loss function configuration(`ch_PP-OCRv3_det_cml.yml`) is shown below. ```yaml Loss: name: CombinedLoss loss_config_list: - DistillationDilaDBLoss: weight: 1.0 model_name_pairs: - ["Student", "Teacher"] - ["Student2", "Teacher"] # 1. Calculate the loss of two Student and Teacher key: maps balance_loss: true main_loss_type: DiceLoss alpha: 5 beta: 10 ohem_ratio: 3 - DistillationDMLLoss: # 2. Add to calculate the loss between two students model_name_pairs: - ["Student", "Student2"] maps_name: "thrink_maps" weight: 1.0 # act: None key: maps - DistillationDBLoss: weight: 1.0 model_name_list: ["Student", "Student2"] # 3. Calculate the loss between two students and GT balance_loss: true main_loss_type: DiceLoss alpha: 5 beta: 10 ohem_ratio: 3 ``` For more specific implementation of `DistillationDilaDBLoss`, please refer to: [distillation_loss.py](https://github.com/PaddlePaddle/PaddleOCR/blob/release%2F2.4/ppocr/losses/distillation_loss.py#L185). For more specific implementations of distillation loss functions such as `DistillationDBLoss`, please refer to: [distillation_loss.py](https://github.com/PaddlePaddle/PaddleOCR/blob/04c44974b13163450dfb6bd2c327863f8a194b3c/ppocr/losses/distillation_loss.py?_pjax=%23js-repo-pjax-container%2C%20div%5Bitemtype%3D%22http%3A%2F%2Fschema.org%2FSoftwareSourceCode%22%5D%20main%2C%20%5Bdata-pjax-container%5D#L148) #### 2.2.3 Post-processing In the task of detecting knowledge distillation, the post-processing configuration of detecting distillation is as follows. ```yaml PostProcess: name: DistillationDBPostProcess # The post-processing of the DB detection distillation task, inherited from the standard DBPostProcess class model_name: ["Student", "Student2", "Teacher"] # Extract the output of multiple sub-networks and decode them. The network that does not require post-processing is not set in model_name thresh: 0.3 box_thresh: 0.6 max_candidates: 1000 unclip_ratio: 1.5 ``` Taking the above configuration as an example, the output of the three subnets `Student`, `Student2` and `Teacher` will be calculated at the same time for post-processing calculations. Since there are multiple inputs, there are also multiple outputs returned by post-processing. For a more specific implementation of `DistillationDBPostProcess`, please refer to: [db_postprocess.py](../../ppocr/postprocess/db_postprocess.py#L195) #### 2.2.4 Metric Calculation In the knowledge distillation task, the metric calculation configuration is as follows. ```yaml Metric: name: DistillationMetric base_metric_name: DetMetric main_indicator: hmean key: "Student" ``` Since distillation needs to include multiple networks, only one network metrics needs to be calculated when calculating the metrics. The `key` field is set to `Student`, it means that only the metrics of the `Student` network is calculated. Model Structure #### 2.2.5 Fine-tuning Distillation Model There are three ways to fine-tune the detection distillation task: - `ch_PP-OCRv3_det_distill.yml`, The teacher model is set to the model provided by PaddleOCR or the large model you have trained. - `ch_PP-OCRv3_det_cml.yml`, Use cml distillation. Similarly, the Teacher model is set to the model provided by PaddleOCR or the large model you have trained. - `ch_PP-OCRv3_det_dml.yml`, Distillation using DML. The method of mutual distillation of the two Student models has an accuracy improvement of about 1.7% on the data set used by PaddleOCR. In fine-tune, you need to set the pre-trained model to be loaded in the `pretrained` parameter of the network structure. In terms of accuracy improvement, `cml` > `dml` > `distill`. When the amount of data is insufficient or the accuracy of the teacher model is similar to that of the student, this conclusion may change. In addition, since the distillation pre-training model provided by PaddleOCR contains multiple model parameters, if you want to extract the parameters of the student model, you can refer to the following code: ```sh # Download the parameters of the distillation training model wget https://paddleocr.bj.bcebos.com/PP-OCRv3/chinese/ch_PP-OCRv3_det_distill_train.tar ``` ```python import paddle # Load the pre-trained model all_params = paddle.load("ch_PP-OCRv3_det_distill_train/best_accuracy.pdparams") # View the keys of the weight parameter print(all_params.keys()) # Extract the weights of the student model s_params = {key[len("Student."):]: all_params[key] for key in all_params if "Student." in key} # View the keys of the weight parameters of the student model print(s_params.keys()) # Save paddle.save(s_params, "ch_PP-OCRv3_det_distill_train/student.pdparams") ``` Finally, the parameters of the student model will be saved in `ch_PP-OCRv3_det_distill_train/student.pdparams` for the fine-tune of the model.